Ninja vs Breville Toastie Maker
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Ninja and Breville are not really making the same product. Breville sells classic sandwich toasters that seal bread into crimped triangles; Ninja's toastie option is a multi-function appliance, the Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press, that toasts bread, grills and presses panini. If you want the traditional British toastie, Breville wins. If you want one appliance that replaces your toaster and also does good pressed sandwiches, the Ninja makes more sense.
Quick answer: Pick Breville (for example the Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster, VST041) for sealed, generously filled toasties at a fraction of the price. Pick Ninja if you want to replace your pop-up toaster with one appliance that also grills and presses panini-style sandwiches, and you have the budget and worktop space.
On this page
At a glance
| Breville deep fill sandwich toaster | Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Dedicated sealed sandwich toaster | Slot toaster that flips into a horizontal grill, with a panini press accessory |
| UK model codes | VST041 (Deep Fill) | ST200UK (black), ST202UK (stainless steel) |
| Toastie style | Sealed, cut triangles | Pressed, open-edged sandwich |
| Other functions | Toasties only | Toast, bagel, defrost, grill, panini, bake, reheat |
| Power | Typical sandwich toaster wattage | Listed at 2,400W |
| Typical price band | Roughly £25–£40 | Roughly £100–£180 |
Prices are typical bands only; check the current price. Ninja specs are from Ninja's UK listings.
Round 1: The toastie itself
Breville's deep fill plates press the edges of the bread together and cut the sandwich into two sealed pockets. That seal is what makes a British toastie: cheese stays in, beans do not escape, and the edges go crisp and crimped. Read our Breville Deep Fill review for the detail.
The Ninja's panini mode presses a sandwich between hot surfaces, giving a flat, crisp, evenly browned result more like a café panini or a US grilled cheese. It does not crimp or seal the edges, so loose or wet fillings need more care. If you are unsure which style you prefer, our toastie maker vs panini press guide covers it in depth.
Winner: Breville for the classic sealed toastie; Ninja for pressed sandwiches.
Round 2: Versatility
This is the Ninja's whole point. In vertical mode it is a toaster with a long, wide slot; flip it flat and it grills and presses. Its listed functions include toast, bagel, defrost, grill, panini, bake and reheat. If your kitchen is short on space, swapping a toaster and a sandwich maker for one Ninja can make sense.
The Breville deep fill does one job. If you want more functions from Breville, its 3-in-1 machines add waffle and grill plates for not much more money; see Breville 3-in-1 toastie maker and our best 3-in-1 picks.
Winner: Ninja.
Round 3: Speed and ease of use
A sandwich toaster is about as simple as kitchen appliances get: plug in, wait for the ready light, fill, close, wait a few minutes. There are no settings to choose.
The Ninja has a control panel and modes, which adds flexibility but also a small learning curve. With its high listed wattage it heats quickly, but you will spend a minute working out the right mode and time for your sandwich at first. For general timings across appliances, see how long to cook a toastie.
Winner: Breville for simplicity.
Round 4: Size, storage and cleaning
A 2-slice Breville sandwich toaster is compact and can stand on its end in a cupboard. Fixed plates need wiping clean in place, though Breville also sells removable-plate models.
The Ninja is larger and heavier (Ninja lists it at around 4.5kg), and it is designed to live on the worktop as your everyday toaster. It comes with a crumb tray and bake tray. Cleaning involves more parts but the trays are removable. Our cleaning guide covers both appliance types.
Winner: Breville for small kitchens; Ninja if it replaces your toaster anyway.
Round 5: Price and value
There is a big price gap. A Breville deep fill sandwich toaster typically costs a fraction of the Ninja. If all you want is toasties, the Ninja is poor value for that alone. Its value case only works if you would otherwise be buying a new toaster and a grill or panini press as well.
Winner: Breville on value for toasties.
What about Ninja's other grills?
Ninja also sells larger health grills and air fryer-grill combinations. These can make a pressed sandwich, but they are not designed as toastie makers and are bulky for the job. If you are considering one for toasties, read our Ninja toastie maker guide, our toastie maker vs health grill comparison and toastie maker vs air fryer.
Who each one suits
- Breville suits: anyone who wants the traditional crimped British toastie, households who make toasties several times a week, students and small kitchens, and anyone on a budget. It is also the better choice for wet fillings such as beans or chilli, which a press cannot contain.
- Ninja suits: people replacing an old pop-up toaster anyway, households who want grilled cheese, panini, bagels and reheated pastries from one machine, and kitchens where one large appliance on the worktop is preferable to three small ones in a cupboard.
- Neither suits: anyone limited to a microwave, for example in student halls; see microwave toastie makers instead.
It is also reasonable to own both: a Breville for proper toasties and a Ninja as the daily toaster. Given the price of a sandwich toaster, adding one to a Ninja kitchen costs very little.
Final recommendation
For the classic toastie, buy a Breville sandwich toaster: cheaper, simpler, smaller and better at sealing. Choose the Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 if you are replacing a toaster, want grill and panini functions in the same footprint, and prefer pressed sandwiches to sealed ones.
Breville Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster (VST041)
The benchmark British sandwich toaster: deep plates, tight seal, crisp crimped edges and a low price.
- Proper sealed triangles
- Very simple to use
- Compact, inexpensive
- Does one job
- Fixed plates
Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press
A toaster that turns into a grill and panini press. Good if you want one appliance on the worktop rather than three.
- Toast, grill, panini, bake and more
- Replaces a pop-up toaster
- Much more expensive
- Does not seal toasties
- Larger and heavier
More options: best toastie maker, best panini press and all comparisons.
FAQs
Does Ninja make a toastie maker?
Ninja does not focus on a classic sealed sandwich toaster in the UK. Its closest product is the Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press, which presses sandwiches rather than sealing them.
Is the Ninja 3-in-1 worth it just for toasties?
Usually not. It costs several times more than a good sandwich toaster. It makes sense if you also want a new toaster and grill functions in one appliance.
What is the difference between ST200UK and ST202UK?
Ninja lists the ST200UK in black and the ST202UK in stainless steel. They are presented as the same 3-in-1 appliance in different finishes; check Ninja's UK site for any other differences.
Can the Ninja make a cheese toastie that does not leak?
Because it presses rather than seals, keep the cheese away from the edges and avoid overfilling. Firmer, grated cheese works better than slices that slide out. Our leak guide has more tips.