Toastie Maker Brands Compared

By toastiemaker.com ยท Updated

Most toastie makers sold in the UK come from a dozen brands, and the differences between them are real: plate depth, coating quality, how well the edges seal, and whether the plates come out for washing. These guides explain each brand's range in plain terms and tell you which model to buy.

Short version: Breville is the benchmark for deep-fill, properly sealed toasties. Morphy Richards' Mico is the microwave option most people mean when they search for one. Tower, Salter and Quest cover tight budgets, and Ninja and Cuisinart sit at the premium end.

How to read a toastie maker brand

Three things separate brands more than styling does. First, plate depth: "deep fill" plates take thick bread and generous fillings, while shallow plates suit thin sliced bread and leak less. Second, sealing and cutting edges: the classic triangle toastie needs a raised rim that crimps the bread shut. Third, cleaning: removable plates add cost but make the machine far easier to live with. Our toastie maker buying guide covers each in depth.

All brand guides

  • Breville 3-in-1 Snack Maker review

    Breville 3 in 1 toastie maker review: the VST098 Ultimate Snack Maker's toastie, panini and waffle plates, cleaning, storage, pros, cons and alternatives.

  • Breville VST041 Deep Fill review

    Breville Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster VST041 review: specs, design, toastie results, cleaning, owner-reported issues, verdict and the best alternatives.

  • Breville toastie makers: which to buy

    Breville toastie makers compared: Deep Fill VST041, Ultimate VST082, Stuff 'n' Press VST101 and the 3-in-1 VST098. Which to buy, plates, cleaning and prices.

  • Cuisinart sandwich makers

    Cuisinart toastie makers in the UK: the 2-in-1 Grill and Sandwich Maker, waffle options, build quality, guarantee and whether the premium price is worth it.

  • Daewoo sandwich makers

    Daewoo toastie makers in the UK: deep fill 2-portion models and the SDA1562 3-in-1 snack maker compared, with an honest verdict and better alternatives.

  • George Foreman grills for toasties

    Can a George Foreman grill make toasties? How health grills compare with sealed toastie makers, removable plate models, and which to buy in the UK.

  • Lakeland toastie makers

    Lakeland toastie makers: what Lakeland typically stocks, the CRIMPiT toastie sealer, premium brands like Sage and Cuisinart, guarantees and how to choose there.

  • Morphy Richards Mico toastie maker

    Morphy Richards Mico microwave toastie maker guide: how it works, timings by microwave wattage, how to use it, cleaning, honest limits and our verdict.

  • Morphy Richards toastie makers

    Morphy Richards toastie makers explained: electric sandwich makers, the 4-slice model and the Mico microwave toastie maker. Which to buy, cleaning and prices.

  • Ninja toastie maker options

    Is there a Ninja toastie maker? What Ninja actually sells in the UK for toasties: the Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill and Panini Press, health grills and air fryers.

  • Quest budget sandwich makers

    Quest toastie makers reviewed from specs: budget deep fill, 2-portion and 3-in-1 models, what you get for the money, reliability and better-value alternatives.

  • Russell Hobbs sandwich toasters

    Russell Hobbs toastie makers explained: deep fill, 4-portion and 3-in-1 Creations models, removable plates, price bands and which one to buy in the UK.

  • Sage panini presses

    Sage toastie makers in the UK: The Perfect Press sandwich press and BBQ & Press Grill explained, how they differ from sealed toastie makers, and who should buy.

  • Salter toastie makers compared

    Salter toastie makers compared: the EK2143 Deep Fill 3-in-1, the Kuro XL and Aspen XL PFAS-free snack makers. Which Salter to buy, cleaning, warranty and value.

  • Swan sandwich makers

    Swan toastie makers in the UK: what Swan actually sells, the Retro and Nordic styling question, and the best matching sandwich toasters to buy instead.

  • Tefal Snack Collection

    Tefal toastie makers explained: the Snack Collection with interchangeable plates, how the plate system works, what it costs over time and who should buy one.

  • Tower toastie makers: best value

    Tower toastie makers reviewed: the T27032 3-in-1 deep fill, basic sandwich makers and colour ranges. Which Tower to buy, plates, warranty and price bands.

  • VonShef budget 3-in-1

    VonShef toastie makers explained: the 3-in-1 sandwich, waffle and grill maker, plate size issues with UK bread, honest verdict and better budget alternatives.

Brand head-to-heads

Choosing between two names already? These comparisons line the ranges up side by side.

  • Breville vs Morphy Richards

    Breville vs Morphy Richards toastie makers compared: deep fill sealing, range, microwave Mico option, cleaning, price bands and which brand suits which kitchen.

  • Breville vs Russell Hobbs

    Breville vs Russell Hobbs toastie makers: deep fill sealing, 3-in-1 value, cleaning, build, price bands and a clear verdict on which brand suits your toasties.

  • Deep fill or standard plates?

    Deep fill vs standard (shallow) toastie maker plates compared: filling capacity, sealing, bread fit, browning, cleaning and price, with a clear pick for each cook.

  • Microwave vs electric toastie maker

    Microwave vs electric toastie makers compared on results, speed, running cost, space, cleaning and safety rules, with a clear verdict on who should buy which.

  • Ninja vs Breville

    Ninja vs Breville for toasties: the Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press vs a Breville deep fill on results, versatility, space and price.

  • Can an air fryer replace a toastie maker?

    Can an air fryer replace a toastie maker? Results, cooking time, running cost, cleaning and versatility compared, plus the foil trick for air fryer toasties.

For a ranked shortlist across every brand, see the best toastie makers in the UK.